The short answer
Torsion springs mount on a shaft above the door and twist. Extension springs run along the horizontal tracks on each side and stretch. Torsion springs are smoother, safer when they break, and generally last longer: about 10,000 to 20,000 cycles, compared with 5,000 to 15,000 for extension springs. At four cycles a day, a standard 10,000-cycle spring lasts about seven years. Either kind should be replaced by a trained technician, because both hold enough tension to cause serious injury.
Updated . General information for the Springfield, MO area. Prices are typical market ranges, not a quote.
How to tell which you have
Close the door and look from inside. If there is a steel shaft across the wall above the door with one or two thick coils on it, those are torsion springs. If the wall above the door is bare and there is a long, thinner spring running back along each horizontal track toward the opener, those are extension springs.
Most houses built in the Springfield area since the 1990s have torsion springs. Extension springs are common on older single doors and on mid-century garages around town.
How each one works
A torsion spring is wound tight when the door is closed. As the door rises, the spring unwinds and turns the shaft. The shaft has a grooved drum at each end, and each drum reels in a cable attached to the bottom corner of the door. The spring's twist becomes lift.
An extension spring is stretched when the door is closed, like a screen door spring scaled up. Each one pulls on a cable through a pair of pulleys. As the door rises the spring contracts. There is one per side, and the two work independently, which is why a door on extension springs can lift unevenly when one weakens.
Cycle life, turned into years
Springs are rated in cycles. One cycle is one opening and one closing. Door manufacturers say most residential springs are built for about 10,000 cycles. Published ranges run 10,000 to 20,000 for torsion springs and 5,000 to 15,000 for extension springs.
| Cycles per day | 10,000-cycle spring | 20,000-cycle spring |
|---|---|---|
| 2 (one car, out and back) | 10,000-cycle springAbout 14 years | 20,000-cycle springAbout 27 years |
| 4 (two cars) | 10,000-cycle springAbout 7 years | 20,000-cycle springAbout 14 years |
| 6 (two cars plus errands) | 10,000-cycle springAbout 4.5 years | 20,000-cycle springAbout 9 years |
| 8 (family using it as the front door) | 10,000-cycle springAbout 3.5 years | 20,000-cycle springAbout 7 years |
Count your own for a week. Most people guess low. Kids on bikes, the mower and the trash cans all count.
What shortens a spring's life here
- Cold. Steel is more brittle at low temperatures, and springs break most often in cold weather with the door down. Springfield's first run of mornings in the teens produces a wave of broken springs every winter.
- Rust. The Ozarks are humid, more so in late summer. Rust between the coils adds friction and pits the wire. A light spray of garage door lubricant on the coils twice a year helps.
- The wrong spring. A spring that is too small for the door works harder on every cycle. This happens when a door is insulated or reinforced after installation, or when a past repair used whatever was on the truck.
What happens when each kind breaks
A torsion spring breaks with a loud bang, and then it sits there. The spring is wrapped around the shaft, so the broken pieces stay on the bar. You will see a gap in the coils. The door becomes dead weight.
An extension spring is under tension in open air. If it breaks without a safety cable, the pieces can fly the length of the garage, and they have gone through car windows and drywall. The industry's safety guidance calls for a containment cable threaded through the center of each extension spring and anchored at both ends. If your extension springs have no cable through them, have cables added. It is an inexpensive job.
Converting from extension to torsion
When extension springs wear out, many techs will offer to convert the door to a torsion system. It needs a few inches of clear wall above the door for the shaft. The door runs smoother, the parts last longer, and the flying-spring hazard goes away. Typical cost is $400 to $800 in general market terms, against $120 to $200 to replace the extension springs like for like. On a door you plan to keep ten years, conversion is usually money well spent. On a tired door you may replace soon, new extension springs with safety cables are enough.
What to ask when a spring is replaced
- What is the cycle rating of the spring you are installing?
- Are you replacing both springs? On a two-spring door the answer should be yes.
- Did you size it by measuring the old spring or by weighing the door?
- Will you check the cables, drums and bearings while the tension is off?
- What is the warranty on the part, and separately on the labor?
Then watch the balance test at the end. With the opener disconnected and the door at waist height, it should stay where it is left.
Questions
How long do garage door springs last?
Standard springs are rated for about 10,000 cycles. That is roughly seven years at four cycles a day, and under four years at eight a day. High-cycle springs double that or better.
Can I replace just one torsion spring?
You can, but it is poor economy. Both springs have the same wear, the door ends up unevenly balanced, and you will likely pay for a second visit within the year.
Are torsion springs better than extension springs?
For most doors, yes. They lift more evenly and last longer, and a broken one stays on the shaft. Extension springs are acceptable on light single doors as long as they have safety cables.
Is a lifetime spring warranty worth paying for?
Read the terms first. Many cover the spring and leave you paying labor and a trip charge each time, and no spring lasts forever. A high-cycle spring at a fair price is often the better deal.
