What the spring does
The opener does not lift your door. The springs do. A double steel door weighs somewhere around 150 to 250 pounds, and the springs are wound to offset almost all of it. A door in good balance can be lifted with one hand. The opener only has to guide it.
When a spring breaks, the opener is suddenly trying to lift the full weight. Most will not. The ones that try can strip their drive gear or bend the top section of the door, which turns one repair into two. That is why the first advice is always the same: stop pressing the button.
How long springs last, and why they break in January
Standard residential springs are rated for about 10,000 cycles. One cycle is the door going up and coming back down. A household that uses the garage as the front door can run six or eight cycles a day, which puts a standard spring at four or five years. Two cycles a day stretches that past a decade.
Steel gets more brittle in the cold, so a spring near the end of its life tends to let go on a cold morning. Springfield's average January low is about 24 degrees, and the first hard snap of the winter is when the calls stack up. Humidity does its part the rest of the year. Rust on the coils adds friction and shortens the life of the steel.
More on spring types and cycle ratings in torsion vs extension springs.
What a proper spring job includes
- Springs matched to the door. Springs are sized by wire thickness, inside diameter and length, and the right size depends on the weight and height of your door. A tech should measure the old spring or weigh the door, not guess.
- Both springs replaced on a two-spring door. They were installed together and have done the same number of cycles. The second one is not far behind.
- A look at the cables, drums, end bearings and center bearing while the tension is off. A frayed cable is cheap to replace during a spring job and expensive to ignore.
- A balance test at the end. With the opener disconnected, the door should stay put when it is left half open. If it drifts down or creeps up, the spring is the wrong size or needs adjusting.
- A check of the opener's travel and force settings, since they were set for the old spring.
What it typically costs
| Job | Typical range |
|---|---|
| Torsion spring, one-car door | Typical range$150 to $350 |
| Pair of torsion springs, 16x7 double door | Typical range$300 to $500 |
| Extension springs, pair | Typical range$120 to $200 |
| High-cycle springs with new bearings | Typical range$600 to $750 |
| Converting extension springs to torsion | Typical range$400 to $800 |
Be wary of a spring price far above these. Homeowners around the country have posted invoices of $1,500 and more for a standard spring change, usually after a low-priced tune-up coupon got a salesman in the door. Ask for the total before the tech starts, and ask what the spring's cycle rating is.
Why this is not a weekend project
A wound torsion spring holds enough energy to lift the door, and winding a new one means putting that energy in by hand with steel bars, a quarter turn at a time. If a bar slips or a set screw strips, the bar and your hand are in the way. The door industry's own safety guidance says springs, cables and bottom brackets should be adjusted only by a trained technician.
Spring replacement: questions
Can I open the door by hand with a broken spring?
With the door closed, you can pull the release and try, but you will be lifting the full weight of the door, often 150 pounds or more, and it will not stay up. Two strong adults can sometimes get a car out and prop the door with locking pliers on the track. It is safer to wait.
Should both springs be replaced if only one broke?
Yes, on a two-spring door. Both springs have the same number of cycles on them. Replacing one leaves the door out of balance and usually means a second service call within months.
How long does a spring replacement take?
A tech with the right springs on the truck usually finishes a standard residential door in about an hour. Odd sizes or heavy wood doors can mean ordering a spring.
What is a high-cycle spring?
A spring built from longer or heavier wire so it is rated for more cycles than the standard 10,000, commonly 20,000 or more. It costs more up front. It makes sense if you use the door many times a day.
